I wanted some different dessert for my Dec 23 family gathering of 30 people. I read about this bakery and took the ride and ordered some things. Thought the prices were definitely high but I always say you get what you pay for. I also thought everything looked good. I went on the 21 st to order it and was going to pick up Saturday the 23 rd between 11- 12. I got there at 11:30 no idea who I was gave them the receipt. They said what is the name under I said John. Looked came back asked if it could be another name I said no I said here is the receipt. After 3-4 minutes the two young ladies talking in the back came out and said sorry but the order is not ready. We can have it ready in 15 minutes. I was in a time crunch with a lot of running around. I did ask is 15 minutes an accurate number they said yes. Well I was not expecting to get all the stuff that was sitting in the shelves and the freezers for days but I had no other choice. If you figure it out it’s almost 100 dollars for a cheesecake or 11 per slice They threw things on the 11 dollar a slice cheesecake that was frozen or sitting in the refrig for days as you can see from photo they rushed and the amount of topping they threw on was disgusting. We all had a small taste but only one person liked any of it except the banana pudding two people loved it. As for me. I hated the cheesecake. There was so much toppings you didn’t even taste the cheesecake it was impossible. The Nutella cookies were so hard they must have been there for days. LILI cake No good. I did enjoy the banana pudding. As you see the amount of money I spent and threw away at least half of the stuff. I am reviewing this on what we had and I do think the young ladies just throwing things on was a big problem. I did leave one slice of cheesecake in the refrig and three days later the inside was brown not sure if it was from the caramel or not. I received a text an hour after my order that I get 10 % off next order but needs to be in the next three days. Thought that was a little tacky after I spent over 200 bucks. Maybe next 30 days would be nice . I give honest reviews but this place is way too expensive I would never go back but a 200 dollar order should be made fresh and ready for pick up when the customer comes for it. Atmosphere was nice presentation is nice place was decorated gorgeous. By the way I paid on the 21 st to make it easier on the pick up guess what I could have left if I didn’t do that.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 3
Recommended dishes
One Macaron
I ordered this cake two days before I needed it. I sent a picture of what I wanted and they were spot on! The cake was GORGEOUS!! Everyone loved it. Also, the shop was beautiful. I can’t wait to go back and try all the yummy looking treats.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Everything is just a tasty as it looks, if not tastier!
I've tried a few different things there form time to time and i have been disappointed yet!
My friend and i got maccarons, cookies and milkshake from there and it was definitely worth it.
Service
Dine in
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Nutella Stuffed Cookie Dough
When we first heard about this place, we didn't know what to expect. All we knew is that a very young girl, with a passion for baking, inspired her father to open a bakery in NYC. Due to its popularity, they opened a new location in North Babylon, NY (Suffolk County). Being so close to home, we had to get here ASAP! Fast forward to present day, SPOILER ALERT, we are regulars at this bakery!
Walking in, you are greated with a variety of heavenly, decadent desserts from macarons to their popular four layered cheesecake (chocolate chip cookie, oreos, cheesecake, then brownie...the perfect collaboration). What really caught our eyes was the display of 18 varieties of cheesecake-on-a-stick...YES PLEASE! Cheesecake dipped into melted chocolate and decorated (right in front of you) in an assortment of toppings from oreos to fruity pebbles, don't forget about the drizzles! They do have your basic bakery items with the best ingredients, and everything is made fresh at shop, and baked to perfection...they also have milkshakes! I do wish they sold cups of coffee, but what can you do!
When all is completed, don't forget to show off your purchases in front of the beautiful floral instagram wall complete with a neon sign! By the way...they are open until 12am every night and are on the basic food delivery apps.
If you made it this far, TIPS:
-enter your phone number at the register to earn yourself sweet rewards!
-leave a google review for a FREE macaron.
-this is a large parking lot, parking is zero issue!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Brookie Bar
I needed to place a last minute custom cupcake order and Made by Lilis came through clutch!! They’re so accommodating and the cupcakes came out even better than I expected!! We frequent the bakery for treats often and everything is always fresh and delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
I ordered my Birthday cake from Made by Lilis Bake Shop.. it was absolutely gorgeous!! They brought my vision to life and made it within a few days. I was late to ordering my cake and I was so grateful they were able to create such a beautiful cake!! Not only was the cake gorgeous it was absolutely delicious!! I've been in there a few times for other desserts and they are delicious!! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND for all dessert and occasional needs!! They have an assortment of different delicious desserts from desserts in jars, cookies, cupcakes, macaroons, cake slices, dessert bars, icecream and more!! Great vibes and staff was extremely helpful and friendly!!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
HOW DID I NEVER KNOW ABOUT THIS BAKERY!!!! Absolutely outstanding desserts, the whole staff was so informative & welcoming!!! You have to try the dipped cheesecake!!! This is my new favorite spot & I will most definitely be back!!! Recommending this place to absolutely everyone, the range of desserts is insane! On top of all of that, they are open late! The place is not only so beautiful & chill it’s also super clean!
I had the pleasure to try Lili's red velvet cupcake, and it was such a delight. Perfect balance of vanilla and chocolate, the icing was smooth and creamy. It was so lovely.
I can't wait to be back and try the French macarons. She nailed the red velvet cupcake, and I will happily try everything else.
Adorable and delicious! So many choices it is hard to pick.
Updating review post visit:
I went Friday evening around 10PM to Made by Lilis bake shop. There was a ton of Macaroons in all different flavors and colors as soon as you walk in the door. They also had banana pudding, cookie /cake jars. An ice cream station just past that, then a cheesecake and brownie station with chocolate coatings and tons of topping choices. Followed only by a case full of beautiful cupcakes in an array of flavors. The back portion of the shop where the baking happens is an open view which is nice to be able to physically see the cleanliness as well as people working on orders. There is very minimal seating available inside and no outdoor seating but this would still be a great choice to bring items to an event or for a surprise treat.
I didn’t take a picture of the milkshake I got but it was amazing as well! This is the lili’s cake and it was so rich and decadent, I had to save the other half for tomorrow! The owner greeted us upon entrance and didn’t make us feel stressed out to order immediately. After the first sip of our milkshakes we were already planning our next visit.
